Images of protestant leaders should also be prohibited by authorities
Molanus argues that images of protestant reformers and other heritical figures should be prohibited by authorities.
The resurrection of Christ took place from a closed tomb
Molanus affirms that the resurrection of Christ should be depicted with a closed tomb and not with an open as some painters tend to do
Lascivious images should be banned
Molanus argues that indecent and lascivious art, such as naked Venuses or Satyrs, should be forbidden because they are prostitution to the eye.
Useful representations derived from the pagans
Molanus discusses the usefulness of antique images of cities and countries.
Arnau Dandes does not believe in images
Arnau Dandes, a native of France, disbelieved in the image of Mary and of God
The monstrous
The participants have already spoken about grotesques (monstrosities) in advance.
The correct way of representing the clothes of Christ in the “The procession to Calvary with the cross”
The Passion of Christ iconography was an important topic for Pacheco. The author in this passage analyses the scene of “The procession to Calvary with the cross”, and presented the artwork made by Luis de Vargas as an example of an inadequate manner of depicting Christ: wearing only one tunic, instead of two garments on him, mantle, and skirt (the correct manner).
The Virgin Mary meditating on our redemption during the Annunciation
The position of Mary at the moment of the annunciation is not clearly described in the Scriptures, therefore painters should depict her according to the common opinion on this matter and what seems most probable from the Scriptures.
Christ seated on the cold stone
Molanus affirms that the depiction of Christ on a stone is not an error despite not being derived from the Scriptures.
It is useful to write the names of lesser-known saints and martyrs in their paintings
Molanus argues that because of the large number of saints, it is advisable to write their names as captions in the paintings.
Faith, Hope, and Charity and their mother, Wisdom, are official martyrs of the Church
Molanus argues that the Three Graces and their mother have a very long tradition in the Church and attempts to remove them from the litanies should not be tolerated.
An iconography no longer used of St. Anne
Pacheco is very clear: artists should erase forever from their memories what was one time a valid model of depicting Saint Anne, who was seated, with the Virgin Mary and Jesus as a child in her arms, and accompanied by three husbands, three daughters, and many grandchildren.
How to represent St. Philip (and how not to do it)
Depicting St. Philip as a eunuch is inadequate according to Pacheco study of the iconography of the saint. The author states that “there is no foundation for painting the holy Apostle as a eunuch, but as El Mudo [Juan Fernández de Navarrete] painted him in El Escorial, following Raphael: as a venerable old man, eighty-seven years of age”.
Children cannot receive beneficiaries
Molanus condemns the depiction of the story of Salome since it could provide a false argument for giving beneficiaries to children.
The decoration of churches is an ancient practice, but should not be done in a profane manner
Molanus confirms that the decoration of churches and other sacred places is an old Biblical tradition, however profane decorations are not allowed.
Idols should not be used as artistic motifs
Molanus condemns pagan artworks as idols that need to be abolished but also emphasises that what is allowed in writing is also allowed in art.
Series of twelve images with the Passion of Christ, which are considered suspect of Lutheranism
Edict of the Holy Office of Mexico describing some cavases that allegedly entered the kingdom and recommending that they be collected so that they do not continue to circulate. The Inquisition express the fear that the images convey Lutheran errors
On bearded Angels and the Crucifixion
In this part of the dialogue, the characters discuss the artists of the past.
Images of the Trinity in the bosom of the Virgin Mary are devoid of beauty and religion
Molanus criticises a particular type of statue of the Virgin Mary that could be opened up and held an image of the Trinity in this inner compartment. According to him, this creates a wrong illusion about the relationship between Virgin Mary and the Trinity.
Christ kneeling for the Father
Molanus argues that Christ did not kneel for his Father, condemning it as humiliating and a sign of indignity.
The placement of saints in images should not lead to questions about their position in heaven
Molanus discusses the question of the placement of a saint in an artwork and the assumed correspondence to its position in heaven, but he argues that one should not worry too much about this.
Moral images of Christian origin
Molanus nuances the usefulness to moral instruction of profane art in comparison to Christian writings and art since they offer much more examples.
Disbelief in the image of the crucifix
Jeanne d’Obaque, from the Béarn area, disbelieving in the image of the crucifix, hit the object several times
The extent of the poetic license
After the participants had already limited the poetic licence, now follows the final definition of the licence (at least for poetic painting).